Inside this article
When a newsroom or publisher uses AI to transcribe interviews, search documents, summarize research, or draft copy, the tool shapes what readers see. One person remains responsible for the finished work. Treat AI output as something to verify, not proof that a claim is true.
Set limits before use, check important claims against their original evidence, and give editors authority to hold or escalate a story. Review formatting help lightly. Check an allegation, quotation, or image shaped by AI more closely.
Decide what AI may do
Decide how staff may use AI before publication work begins. An editor or author should be able to say what task the tool will perform, what information will go into it, and who will check the result. That decision helps staff distinguish support tasks, such as transcription or document search, and AI output that could change a story’s facts or framing.
News organizations draw different boundaries. The Associated Press says staff may experiment cautiously with generative AI, but says staff must treat its output as information they have not checked and does not use it to create publishable content under its 2023 guidance. The Washington Post permits support uses such as translation and searching through documents, while stressing that verification remains necessary. These policies reflect different editorial choices, and staff still need to verify AI output under either one.
A publication should write down its own rules for drafting, translation, transcription, image analysis, and other common uses. For example, it might allow AI to produce a rough transcript while requiring the reporter to check every quotation against the recording. It might allow document summaries for navigation, while requiring the author to read the underlying passage before using a claim. A clear rule also tells staff when a use falls outside approved practice and needs an editor’s decision.
Protect unpublished information
Before staff enter reporting material into an AI tool, set rules for what they may upload. Protect confidential drafts, source identities, interview notes, and unpublished documents because some external tools are not approved to receive them. The Associated Press and MPR News both warn staff against entering confidential or sensitive material into AI tools; the Thomson Reuters Foundation’s newsroom guidance also recommends clear rules for unpublished information.
The person assigning the work should identify which tools are approved and what information each tool may receive. If a reporter cannot tell whether a tool is appropriate for a source’s identity or a confidential document, the reporter should stop and ask an editor before uploading anything. A faster summary is not worth exposing a source or unpublished reporting.

Assign named owners
Every story needs a person who owns its claims and a person with authority to approve publication. AI does not take either role. Reuters’ journalistic standards place responsibility on journalists and the organization, and the Associated Press keeps human reporting and editorial judgment central to its guidance.
The author should record when AI made a meaningful contribution and check any facts the tool introduced or changed. A second reviewer should independently check the most consequential claims when the story’s risk warrants it. The editor then reviews the finished version for accuracy, fairness, context, and readiness to publish. The editor must be able to hold the story, request more evidence, seek specialist advice, or reject the material.
Newsrooms do not universally require a separate fact-checker for every AI-assisted story. Smaller publishers can still separate responsibilities where it matters: an editor can check the author’s key claims, or a specialist can review a legal, security, or visual-authenticity issue. The point is to avoid letting the person who relied on AI be the only person deciding whether its output is sound.
Verify claims against evidence
Check important claims against the original evidence, not the AI’s explanation or citations. A citation produced by an AI tool can be incomplete, misquoted, or unrelated to the claim. The author should locate the original source and confirm that it supports the wording, scope, and emphasis in the draft.
Check names, dates, figures, software versions, and quotations directly. Compare summaries with the original document to catch missing qualifications or changes in emphasis. Verify quotations against recordings or transcripts, and attribute claims that readers could reasonably dispute. If a source does not support a claim, remove it or revise the wording to match what the evidence establishes.
Visual material needs its own checks. For a photo, audio clip, or video, establish who created it and when and where it was made. Also check whether its origin and authenticity are clear. Metadata and information about where a file came from can help trace its history, but they do not prove that its contents are true. The Associated Press describes verification practices that check source and authorship, along with timing and location; it advises against using material whose authenticity remains in doubt.
For a more detailed approach to checking claims and citations, see how to verify AI-generated content.
Match review to risk
Use stronger review when an error could harm a person, mislead readers about a consequential issue, or be difficult to undo. Allegations, sensitive personal information, legal or safety implications, synthetic media, and uncertain material should trigger additional checks or specialist review. A routine formatting task can follow a lighter path, provided it does not alter meaning or introduce facts.
This approach directs more review to work where errors could do more harm. A transcript cleanup might need the author to compare the text with the recording. An AI-assisted story about a person’s alleged conduct should receive independent checking of the central claims and an editor’s explicit approval. A suspicious video should be held until its origin and authenticity are established or the story clearly explains what remains unknown.
No single review scheme has been shown to reduce AI-related errors by a specific amount. Newsroom policies and risk guidance support human oversight and verification, but they do not establish a quantified effect for one particular workflow. Use these review steps to direct attention, but do not treat them as a guarantee of accuracy.

Escalate doubts early
Make it clear whom staff should contact when they cannot verify a claim, find a possibly fabricated quotation, encounter uncertain visual material, or spot a privacy, legal, copyright, security, or source-protection concern. Reuters directs journalists to seek Ethics and Standards or legal guidance when they are unsure. The Associated Press directs staff to bring serious errors or potential errors promptly to supervisory editors.
Pause publication of the material until an editor takes responsibility for the concern and decides what to do. The editor can ask for more reporting, consult a specialist, narrow the claim, add clear attribution, or remove the material. Staff should also escalate AI use outside approved tools or tasks rather than quietly treating it as routine.
The same route should remain open after publication. A reader’s report of a material error needs a named editor who can investigate it, decide whether to correct or update the story, and make the change visible. The Associated Press and The Washington Post both describe clear correction practices. Accountability includes what happens after an error appears, not only who approved the first version.
Keep AI review fast and accountable
Save time on discovery and organization, not on verification. AI can help locate passages, produce a first-pass transcript, or group documents for closer reading. The author still checks the underlying material, and the editor still approves the published version. That division lets the tool speed up bounded tasks without making fluent output a substitute for reporting.
Use a compact record for meaningful AI assistance: note the task, the tool, the claims or content that needed extra checking, the reviewer, and any disclosure decision. A short record gives an editor enough context to review the work and helps the publisher understand how a claim entered the draft. It need not become a long report for a low-risk use.
In a small study, journalists and teachers said AI made some tasks more efficient while adding work to verify information and make judgments. That finding points to a trade-off, not a reliable estimate of time saved. There is not enough evidence to say how much time a newsroom-style process saves once checking, editing, and corrections are included. Publishers can assess their own pilot by tracking time to approval, verification and rework time, corrections or material updates, and how often editors hold or escalate work. These measures show what happened in daily work; by themselves, they do not prove that the workflow caused it.
Set a disclosure rule
Tell readers when AI’s role materially affects how content was produced or presented, especially when AI-generated material could be mistaken for a real image, recording, or event. Reuters commits to transparency about generative AI, and the Paris Charter on AI and Journalism calls for distinguishing authentic from synthetic content and disclosing significant AI use. Other policies treat routine editing assistance differently.
A publication should define what counts as significant use and apply that rule consistently. Transcription that a reporter checks may not need the same reader-facing explanation as an image generated by AI or a story largely drafted by AI. Whatever rule the publication sets for disclosure, the editor should record the decision and the publisher should remain accountable for the result.
Created with AI assistance using published sources. Illustrations are AI-generated. Redbag does not claim hands-on testing or exclusive reporting. Check the linked sources for changing product details.
Our approach ↗


