Inside this article
An initial coin offering (ICO) sells digital tokens to fund or launch a project. A token’s terms may let you use a service or vote. They may also entitle you to income or let you redeem it for money or an asset. Some tokens give you no enforceable claim against the project.
Calling a token “utility,” “governance,” or “security” does not determine your rights. Check what you can demand or do, who must honor that right, and what the sale terms and applicable law say.
What ICO token holders can do
A token can provide access to a service, such as using a platform or product. That access right alone does not make you an owner of the issuer, give you a share of its profits, or entitle you to a refund if the service never launches. Some projects sell access tokens before the service exists, leaving buyers dependent on the project delivering what it promised.
A token can also function as a payment method or transferable unit of value. Sending or trading the token does not require the issuer to exchange it for cash. A market price is not a redemption promise.
Other tokens give holders a claim to a specified benefit. The terms might promise repayment, redemption for an asset, interest, or a share of income. Identify who owes the benefit and what conditions apply. Also check what happens if the issuer cannot pay. If a token gives you both service access and economic rights, check each function separately.
Some tokens let holders vote on proposals or participate in a network, such as by helping validate transactions. A vote may cover only certain decisions, and a technical role in a network does not automatically create a contractual promise of rewards. The token’s code and its legal terms answer different questions.
Why labels fall short
“Utility token” describes an intended use, but it does not prove that a service is available or that the holder has a right to a refund. “Governance token” indicates a voting feature, but it does not show how much influence holders have. “Security token” also does not tell you the exact rights attached to a particular token.
Regulators examine the arrangements behind a sale as well as the token’s features. In the United States, the Securities and Exchange Commission’s 2026 interpretation treats a crypto asset’s characteristics and the circumstances of its offer or sale as separate questions. A token’s description does not, by itself, decide how securities laws apply.
Check the documents and code separately. A white paper may describe intended benefits, while sale terms or another agreement set out the issuer’s commitments. Code may enable a transfer or vote, but that function alone does not establish a legal remedy if a promise is broken. Read the documents together and look for a clear promise from a named person or organization.

A vote may not mean control
The SEC’s report on The DAO, a project that sold tokens in 2016, illustrates the gap between having a vote and controlling decisions. Token holders could vote on proposals, but curators controlled which proposals could go forward for funding. The SEC also found that holders had difficulty acting together because they participated separately. It concluded that the voting rights did not give holders meaningful control over the project.
That example does not show that every token gives holders little influence. It shows what to check: who can submit proposals, decide which ones advance, veto proposals, carry out approved decisions, or intervene in an emergency. Holders have less practical authority when they vote on only a few choices than when they control the full decision process.
Check who owes the promise
For a specific token, look for the promised benefit and the party responsible for providing it. Then check whether the benefit is available now, what conditions restrict it, and whether the governing documents make a commitment. Pay attention to fees and eligibility rules. Check expiration dates and lockups, along with any circumstances that suspend access or redemption.
For voting rights, follow a proposal from submission through implementation. For economic rights, look for the exact terms governing income, repayment, or redemption. If the documents do not identify who must honor a right, or what happens when that party fails to do so, the token may offer little practical recourse even if it has a useful technical feature.
Legal rights vary by jurisdiction
Token rules depend on the country and the legal category involved. In the European Union, the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA) defines a utility token as a crypto asset intended only to provide access to a good or service supplied by its issuer. For some offers involving services or goods that do not yet exist, MiCA requires a warning that buyers may be unable to exchange the token for the promised benefit if the project fails or stops.
MiCA also sets specific rights for certain regulated token categories. Holders of covered e-money tokens have a claim against the issuer and may request redemption at par value. Covered asset-referenced tokens also carry redemption rights against the issuer. Those rules apply only to tokens that meet the relevant categories and conditions. They do not create a general redemption right for ICO tokens.
Swiss financial regulator FINMA’s 2018 guidance likewise recognized that tokens can combine payment, access, and investment features. FINMA’s categories and analysis apply to Switzerland and to that guidance. So check which jurisdiction’s rules apply: the same token description does not establish the same rights everywhere.
Created with AI assistance using published sources. Illustrations are AI-generated. Redbag does not claim hands-on testing or exclusive reporting. Check the linked sources for changing product details.
Our approach ↗
